It began well. Staff was personable, location clean and well kept. My ... read more It began well. Staff was personable, location clean and well kept. My second visit to Torello as I was pleased with my initial tire rotation and oil change service. Skip ahead a few months and I bring in my truck which has a leak from the transmission fluid cooling lines. After diagnostic, I get a call with a quote for dealer parts and labor to replace which is high at $1200. I check with my brother who has been a mechanic for 40+ years and he looks up the parts and they come to less than 200. I call back and speak with Mike and he tells me he quoted dealer parts. I explain that truck is a 2009 with 276K miles and there’s no real need for dealer parts and he tells me he can save me a couple of hundred dollars by going aftermarket. I authorize the work based on that discussion. I get a voicemail 5 days later telling me the truck is done and when I call back, the cost is $1650. One of the cooler lines was frozen to the cooler and they ordered the part and installed it without informing me first, so I have little say in the matter at this point. Tell him I will pick up the truck that same day. Their website and signs on the front door give 5 PM as closing time so I have time to pick it up after work. I arrive at 4:30 and my truck is nowhere to be seen and the doors are locked. I knock as I see someone inside and ask if they are closed and I get a nod before they turn around and go back to whatever they were doing. Now I have to take the next morning off from work so I can pick up my truck now that I know when they really close and that I cannot make it in time after work. The next day when I pick up the truck I see that the pricing still reflects dealer pricing to the tune of $750 vs the original $400 quoted for dealer parts (even though we agreed on aftermarket) Mike’s not there and Ashley can’t answer any questions. I pay the $1650, She hands me the key and says the truck should be on the side somewhere. Turns out, it’s blocked in by other vehicles in the fenced in area. Ultimately they pull it out and I leave. I’m pretty livid at this point and I look up the dealer parts and my cost online and find that I could have purchased them all OE for just over $400. So they almost doubled in cost. As if that weren’t bad enough, I go and look at the labels on the parts they actually installed and they are aftermarket. To sum up, they were friendly enough, but ultimately not straight with me about anything but the cost of labor.
The address listed is outdated: they are located at 26 Potter Ave, Pat... read more The address listed is outdated: they are located at 26 Potter Ave, Patchogue, NY. This shop has terrific mechanics, fair prices, and they stand by their work. We have been bringing our cars there for 20 years. They complete the work quickly and are absolutely trustworthy.
They did not come through. I do believe that a failed ignition cylinde... read more They did not come through. I do believe that a failed ignition cylinder can be fixed but apparently he did not want to devote the time to fix it. It took me 8 days to realize that he was not giving my car the service that it needed. I initially tried to give him the benefit of the doubt. But after having to initiate all the calls to his shop and losing confidence, I realized that he was not going to do the job. I ended up towing my car from his shop with no apology from him or no effort to meet me half way with the towing. The address is actually 109 route 112.
